On paper, Marathon was a game that was fated to succeed no matter what. The game had a direct association with the extremely popular Destiny 2, and Sony was funding the game, ensuring there wouldn’t be any shortage of money. However, even with all of these advantages, the game failed to make an impact.
While it’s known that Marathon wasn’t exactly a hit, many gamers may still wonder why that is. Despite not being a bad game from a gameplay or graphical standpoint, what were the reasons for Marathon’s lackluster reception? Especially compared to other games in the genre such as Arc Raiders.
Marathon’s Difficult Barrier to Entry

Many players agree that Marathon’s first-time user experience is very difficult to get into. Players are thrown into complex systems with a hard-to-navigate UI, forcing users to hover over icons to identify basic gear. This lack of clarity is made worse by punishing mechanics such as the heat gauge for movement and a shortage of important resources.
The game has a short tutorial and a Perimeter mode for beginners. However, it isn’t good enough to prepare players for the game. Bungie game director Joe Ziegler later talked about this directly, saying “Marathon for new players can be an overwhelming experience” and that after the short tutorial, players are forced to learn concepts in a harsh environment.
During Marathon’s Server Slam beta, the game only had a 49% increase in copies sold after the event, which wasn’t much compared to Arc Raiders’ huge 80% jump during its beta. Arc Raiders players could understand the loop quickly, while Marathon punished newcomers before they could properly understand the game. Marathon’s beta ended only three days before the full game launched, giving Bungie almost no time to address these issues.
Bungie Made a Game for a Small Audience With a Big Budget

Marathon is having trouble becoming the next big live-service title because, besides Arc Raiders, extraction shooters are a small genre with little community. Marathon doubled down on this by being an unforgiving PvP-focused experience. It has no safe pockets, full loot loss on death, and seasonal wipes every three months. Bungie’s post-launch plans started with a competitive Ranked mode and Cryo Archive, considered one of the hardest modes in any multiplayer game, so it couldn’t appeal to the mainstream audience.
The problem is that Marathon is a game in a niche genre, yet it was funded by Sony. Sony spent $3.6 billion acquiring Bungie, while Marathon’s development costs were reportedly over $200 million. Since then, Sony has recorded a $769 million impairment loss against Bungie’s business and assets. That represents over 20% of the acquisition value.
Alinia Analytics estimated that the game sold 1.2 million copies. This suggests it generated around $55 million in revenue, which isn’t enough to compensate for that investment. Marathon might have great shooting mechanics, but it was built for a specific player base that limits the potential audience.
Can Sony Afford to Wait for Marathon to Recover?

The main question is whether Marathon can have a Rainbow Six Siege-esque recovery later on or if it will become another example such as Concord. Bungie has stated that it is “in it for the long haul,” and the developers have been responding to feedback. There are plans for a PvE-only mode, better onboarding, and UI/UX fixes in future seasons. The game has a devoted player base with high hour counts. On Steam, 22% of players have surpassed 50 hours, and almost 7% have over 100 hours.
However, Sony has slowed down its live-service plans or shut down multiple projects. Examples include the leaked multiplayer expansion for Spider-Man 2, The Last of Us 2 Factions, and a God of War multiplayer project. If Marathon doesn’t generate enough revenue in the next year or so, there’s a chance Sony might drop support for it. This would be a bigger problem than Marathon not being a hit.
